Smiling professor on campus

What percentage of assistant professors get tenure?

Tenure is one of the highest-stakes milestones in an academic career. Yet most institutions say little publicly about how often it’s granted, and those that do can report strikingly different rates depending on how they measure who “gets tenure.” One measure is the cohort rate: of the faculty hired onto the tenure track in a given year, how many eventually earn tenure at that institution? The other is the review rate: of the faculty who go up for review, how many are granted tenure? The cohort rate is almost always lower, because many assistant professors leave before tenure review. Some take jobs elsewhere, some leave academia, and some are counseled that their case is unlikely to succeed and move on before a formal denial ever happens.

A closer look at the tenure rate data

In 2025, the Harvard Crimson reported on data presented to the Faculty of Arts and Sciences showing that about 54 percent of tenure-track faculty ultimately received tenure under Presidents Gay and Garber, compared with about 52 percent under Faust and more than 60 percent under Bacow. Among those who went up for review, about 65 percent succeeded under Gay and Garber, versus roughly 78 percent under Bacow and 72 percent under Faust. The numbers behind these percentages are small, though: the Crimson reports only about four or five denials a year.

Penn State is one of the few universities that publishes this data every year. Its most recent report followed the 180 faculty who entered the tenure track in 2017. Seven years later, 52 percent had earned tenure, nearly a third had left or otherwise not gone up for review, and about 4 percent had been denied tenure. The remaining 12 percent were still on the tenure path. Among those who did go up for tenure (the review rate), 93 percent succeeded. The 2017 cohort rate is probably an undercount, since 39 percent of the cohort paused their tenure clocks, many through a pandemic-era extension.

A 2026 report from the University of Michigan’s ADVANCE Program tracked assistant professors in two five-year cohorts. Of those whose tenure clocks started in academic years 2003 through 2007, 59 percent were promoted with tenure within ten years, compared with 73 percent of those starting in 2008 through 2012. Faculty who earned tenure spent about six years in the assistant rank on average. Michigan’s data doesn’t separate faculty who left before review from those who were denied, so everyone who left is counted as untenured.

These cohort figures aren’t strictly comparable. They follow faculty for different lengths of time (seven years at Penn State, ten at Michigan) and treat departures differently, so the lower figures likely understate how many people eventually earn tenure. At Penn State, for example, the 12 percent still on the tenure path could push the 52 percent figure higher.

A 2012 study by Deborah Kaminski and Cheryl Geisler tracked nearly 3000 STEM faculty across 14 American universities. They found that of those hired as assistant professors, more than 64 percent were promoted to associate professor at the same institution. They also found that, with the exception of mathematics, women and men were generally retained and promoted at the same rate.

These data are incomplete, and the Kaminski and Geisler study is more than a decade old, but together they tell a fairly consistent story. At research universities, even elite private universities like Harvard, fifty percent or more of new tenure-track hires eventually earn tenure at the institution where they were hired. Among those who come up for review, the rate is higher, from about 65 to 93 percent, because much of the attrition happens before the vote, as people leave or are counseled out.

How worried should you be about being denied tenure?

If you’re being counseled to leave before tenure review, you should be very worried. But suppose no one has told you that you’re unlikely to meet the bar. A review rate of 65 to 93 percent is a very wide range, and even at institutions at the top of it, seven percent of faculty who go up for review are turned down. Some worry is reasonable. Still, tenure-track faculty should keep two things in mind.

First, losing faculty is costly for institutions. Searches are time-consuming, and turnover is expensive: Gallup estimates that replacing an employee can cost one-half to two times their annual salary. That estimate covers workers in general and doesn’t account for costs specific to faculty, such as startup packages, which can run to $1 million or more in some fields, or appeals of tenure denials.

Second, departments have a strong reason of their own to see assistant professors through: if a faculty member isn’t tenured, their line might not be renewed, permanently shrinking the department. Of course, faculty are still denied tenure, or advised to find other work before they apply. But the cost of losing someone (and the possibility that they won’t be replaced) is a good reason for your colleagues to want you to succeed.

What can you do to improve your chances?

First, get clear about your tenure requirements. Written tenure and promotion standards are often opaque or vague. Your faculty handbook might say that the standards for tenure and promotion are “notable scholarly or creative activity” or “consistently effective teaching.” But what do these standards actually require? How many publications? In which journals? What counts as “consistently effective”? Some institutions and departments provide more specific requirements, but details are often thin on the ground.

For publication or grant requirements, look at the CVs of departmental colleagues who earned tenure in the past 5 to 10 years. Note how many publications and grants they had by the time they went up for tenure. Keep in mind that a colleague’s CV may include articles that were still forthcoming when their case was decided. Articles published in the year of the review, or the year after, may still have been counted, since some institutions allow a paper that has been accepted but not yet published to be included in the tenure file with written confirmation of acceptance.

Teaching is trickier, since evaluation data isn’t public the way CVs are. If colleagues are willing to share theirs, you can compare it with your own. You can also ask your chair, your dean, or a faculty senate representative how teaching is evaluated in tenure and promotion decisions. If evaluation scores are weighted heavily, what counts as inadequate, adequate, or excellent? What other evidence of teaching effectiveness do the committees consider?

If you’re failing to meet your tenure requirements in some clear and obvious way, urgent action is needed. If you find yourself in this position, it is time to ask for help. Seek out mentors; hire a coach. More often, you’re not clearly falling short, but progress is slow and uncertain. A couple of things are worth remembering. The first is that hiring committees generally aim to hire candidates they believe can earn tenure. The people who hired you thought you could do this.

The second is that when progress is slow and uncertain, you can’t afford to invest time and energy into work your institution doesn’t value. If your institution primarily values research, spending too much time perfecting your teaching is unwise. Becoming a good teacher is a long game, and you can keep honing your craft after tenure. Similarly, many institutions give little weight to encyclopedia entries, book reviews, and book chapters. If yours is one of them, keep them to a minimum. Know exactly what your institution requires and rewards, and be diligent about aligning your work with it.

Second, own your teaching data. Many faculty take the teaching evaluation data their institution gives them and drop it into their file without any organization or storytelling. That can be dangerous. Raw evaluations overload readers, and overloaded readers fall back on cognitive shortcuts. Negativity bias can make a few unrepresentative semesters jump out and unduly influence the evaluation. Anchoring bias can lead evaluators to fixate on early semesters and overlook later improvement. And unfortunately, confirmation bias can mean that someone who doesn’t want to award you tenure goes looking for data that supports their position.

To start, process the data yourself. Alongside the raw scores your institution provides, include your own charts and tables that aggregate your evaluations over time, such as yearly averages or medians along with the number of responses, so a few unrepresentative semesters don’t distort the overall picture. That way readers can see both the full record and the trends, rather than pages of individual scores. I worked with a faculty member who had a few semesters of exceptionally low scores (around 1 out of 5), but when we averaged his scores across all of his courses over seven years, his overall average was above 4 out of 5. The low semesters were outliers, not a trend, and the aggregated data showed he was a consistently strong teacher.

Next, tell the story of your teaching data. If you have some low scores and there are reasons for them, explain those reasons in your teaching narrative. Maybe the low-scoring semesters were ones where very few students completed evaluations (and those who did were upset about their grades), or ones where you tried something new and it failed. Note improvements, too. If your first few years were not great, show how your scores improved and what you did to improve them. And include other evidence of teaching effectiveness, such as classroom observations and teaching workshops or training you’ve completed. The Center for Teaching and Learning (CTL) on your campus can be a valuable resource here.

Above all, keep in mind that teaching evaluations do not speak for themselves. It’s your job to organize the data in a way that makes a strong case that you’ve met the standard for tenure and promotion. Don’t expect your colleagues to make that case for you. 

Third, ensure your tenure application makes a strong argument. Many faculty approach their tenure file the way they do their CV: as a comprehensive record of everything they’ve done. But a tenure file isn’t just a list of accomplishments. It’s an argument—a case addressed to a specific audience for why you meet the specific standards you’re being evaluated against. Most faculty I work with do meet the standards for tenure and promotion at their institutions. What they struggle with is presentation. Their narrative statements describe rather than argue, implicit claims are never made explicit, and supporting materials are left to speak for themselves. They also rarely use their institution’s own evaluative language to connect their work to their tenure requirements. Presentation matters because tenure committees, particularly at higher levels of review, read dozens of files, each hundreds of pages long, and they can easily miss what isn’t clearly stated. A well-constructed file makes your case so clear that even a distracted, skeptical, or hostile reader will find it hard to argue that you haven’t met the standard.

Fourth, set firm boundaries around non-promotable work. The term comes from The No Club by professors Linda Babcock, Brenda Peyser, Lise Vesterlund, and Laurie Weingart. For faculty, non-promotable work is mostly service: refereeing journal articles, advising students, academic program review, routine departmental administration, and events. The authors call this kind of work non-promotable because it is rarely skill-building, largely invisible, often routine, and less central to advancement. Promotable work, by contrast, is visible, requires expertise, and is tied to advancement. In academia, promotable work is primarily research and teaching, with the weight given to each depending on your institution and your role. 

Expectations for service vary from one institution to another, but there is almost always more of it to do than is required or recommended. It can be hard to say no, but it’s an important skill for early-career faculty to learn. Of course, it’s important to be a good academic citizen and to maintain good relationships with your colleagues, but when you go up for tenure, no one is going to say, “Mitch is a few publications short, but remember all those events he attended and committees he joined? Let’s give him tenure anyway.” What they’re more likely to say is, “Mitch is a great guy and a good colleague. It’s too bad he hasn’t made the cut.”